Sample report
PAGA exposure audit
Fictional Company, Inc. — Illustrative sample only
This is not from a real audit. It shows the structure and type of analysis we provide.
Executive summary
This sample illustrates how we quantify PAGA exposure across pay periods and employees. Under California law, penalties are calculated per aggrieved employee per pay period (e.g. $100–$200 per violation type). The 2024 PAGA reforms allow penalty reductions to 15% (if you fix issues before a PAGA notice) or 30% (within 60 days after notice) when you can show "reasonable steps to comply." A documented audit and corrective actions support that defense.
Methodology
We analyze payroll exports, timekeeping records, and wage statements against California requirements: meal and rest break timing and premium pay, Labor Code §226 wage statement requirements, overtime and rounding practices, final pay timing and content, and policy/training documentation. Exposure is estimated using statutory penalty ranges and affected employee–pay-period counts.
Exposure by category
Finding: Meal periods not provided by end of 5th hour in approximately 12% of shifts over the audit period. Rest break timing not documented for 8% of eligible shifts.
Affected: 42 employees × 24 pay periods = 1,008 units
Penalty range: $100–$200 per unit
Estimated exposure: $100,800 – $201,600
Meal & rest breaks — High
Finding: Meal periods not provided by end of 5th hour in approximately 12% of shifts over the audit period. Rest break timing not documented for 8% of eligible shifts.
Affected: 42 employees × 24 pay periods = 1,008 units
Penalty range: $100–$200 per unit
Estimated exposure: $100,800 – $201,600
Wage statement accuracy (Labor Code §226) — High
Finding: Wage statements missing employer address on 3 of 9 required fields in 100% of pay runs. Deduction descriptions incomplete for 15% of statements.
Affected: 50 employees × 26 pay periods = 1,300 units
Penalty range: $50–$100 per unit (first violation); $100–$200 subsequent
Estimated exposure: $65,000 – $260,000
Payroll & timekeeping — Medium
Finding: Time rounding to nearest 15 minutes identified; neutral rounding not consistently applied. 18 instances of missed clock-out requiring manual correction with no audit trail.
Affected: 38 employees × 26 pay periods = 988 units
Penalty range: $100–$200 per unit
Estimated exposure: $98,800 – $197,600
Final pay & separation — Medium
Finding: Final pay issued after statutory deadline in 4 of 12 terminations reviewed. Unused PTO not included in final check in 2 instances.
Affected: 12 terminations (multiple violation types)
Penalty range: Up to 30 days' wages per employee + PAGA penalties
Estimated exposure: $24,000 – $85,000
Policies & training — Medium
Finding: Handbook does not reflect 2024 meal period policy updates. No documented supervisor training on break compliance in the past 18 months.
Affected: Documentation gap; increases penalty exposure across all categories
Penalty range: Aggravates other findings; limits 'reasonable steps' defense
Estimated exposure: N/A (amplifier)
Total estimated exposure (sample)
$288,680 – $744,200
Risk level: High — multiple violation categories with significant employee–pay-period counts. Does not include defense costs or plaintiff attorney fees.
Recommendations
- Implement and document meal/rest break compliance (start by end of 5th hour; premium pay when missed)
- Correct wage statements to include all 9 Labor Code §226 required items
- Review timekeeping rounding; ensure neutral rounding and full audit trail for manual edits
- Enforce final pay on separation within statutory deadlines; include all wages and accrued PTO
- Update handbook and supervisor training; document completion for "reasonable steps" defense
Next steps
ComplianceShield Software continuously monitors these same areas via your payroll and timekeeping systems, so you stay in the "reasonable steps" zone and can qualify for reduced penalties under 2024 PAGA reforms. PAGA Guard Insurance covers defense and indemnity for PAGA and wage-hour claims — the gap most EPLI policies leave uncovered.
Request your free audit →